Let's see if we can connect the dots.
Daniel Dennett and Linda LaScola publish a paper demonstrating that the church is so mired in paranoid superstition that its employed clergy have to lie through their teeth day in and day out just to survive it.
Several commentators from the Washington Post responded. I recommend Dennett's summary of the responses. I thought that was an important paper and commented on it here, A Church Without God.
That post generated 120 comments including interesting conversation on
- realism vs. non-realism,
- whether creeds are fact or fiction and whether or not that matters,
- whether the concept of "God" is a product of evolution or revelation,
- ethics, meaning, and the role of the church when "God" comes "down to Earth",
- the challenges that scholarship has provided to the church and to the clergy who have one foot in the academy and the other in the parish, and so on.
Enter Parker Williamson of the LayMAN. He is not interested in those questions, of course. He is interested in control. He tries his overused bullying tactics in attempt to shame my presbytery into dealing with my "in-your-face apostasy." Ho hum.
I responded that I had been Layed (and I still don't know the correct grammatical form for telling that truth).
This in turn stirs up his faithful to write letters.
I wrote one as well, challenging Mr. Williamson to file a charge. Why does he allow such apostasy and heresy to go unchecked in his church? The BFTSs* have no problem filing charges against gays and lesbians and the ministers who marry them regardless of what presbytery they serve.
So Parker, why be such a wallflower about heretics and apostates? Surely they are worse than gay advocates?
Then I preached an Easter sermon about overcoming bullies.
Following that Lovely and I enjoyed a nice vacation. In between beach time I read more of Daniel Dennett's Darwin's Dangerous Idea: Evolution and the Meanings of Life.
I am realizing more and more that evolution is a dangerous idea.
We are still connecting dots.
Big dangerous ideas, bullies, self-censorship, clergy, bullies, church, bullies, profound thoughts, God, "God?", scholarship, history, science, creeds, bullies, freedom of conscience, paranoia, evolution...
...and I return to find this story, Evangelical Scholar Forced Out After Endorsing Evolution:
When it comes to incriminating videos these days, the one of Bruce K. Waltke might seem pretty tame. It shows the noted evangelical scholar of the Old Testament talking about scholarship, faith and evolution. What was incriminating? He not only endorsed evolution, but said that evangelical Christianity could face a crisis for not coming to accept science.The Reformed Theological Seminary ("A mind for truth, a heart for God") is not affiliated with the PC(USA) however a number of PC(USA) clergy have received their educations there. The seminary that has a "mind for truth" does not have a mind for the dangerous idea of evolution.
"If the data is overwhelmingly in favor of evolution, to deny that reality will make us a cult ... some odd group that is not really interacting with the world. And rightly so, because we are not using our gifts and trusting God's Providence that brought us to this point of our awareness," he says, according to several accounts by those who have seen the video. Those words set off a furor at the Reformed Theological Seminary, where Waltke was — until this week — a professor. (The seminary is evangelical, with ties to several denominations.)
The statements so upset officials of the seminary that Waltke had to ask the BioLogos Foundation, a group that promotes the idea that science and faith need not be incompatible, to remove it from its website (which the foundation did) and to post a clarification. The video was shot during a BioLogos workshop. But even those steps weren't enough for the seminary, which announced that it had accepted his resignation.
Michael Kruse commented on the story:
People sometimes ask me how I can stay with the PCUSA in light of views I have on certain issues. And there is no question that there is a lot of squirrely stuff going on with my tribe. But if you want reasons for why I don't look to more conservative denominations, here is a one prime example. Unbelievable.I haven't met Michael but I think he would describe himself as evangelical. Not sure what he thinks is "squirrely stuff" but he gets it right. Better to put up with a few squirrels than the alternative.
We are getting close to the end of the connect the dots game.
We began with Dennett's five clergy (including a Presbyterian) who are "in the closet" because they hold dangerous ideas that must not be spoken among the supposedly fragile worshipers and their even more fragile, self-proclaimed protectors (LayMAN, Seminary officials).
We witnessed on this very blog and in the recent news the consequences for seeking truth and for being open about the search.
Bullies exist. True enough.
There is a cure.
We stand together.
The strength of our denomination is the most precious freedom we possess, the freedom of conscience.
We need as a church to create and protect a culture of free inquiry. Laity need to be courageous in creating space for clergy to teach and preach what they learn even if (especially if) the ideas they are learning are dangerous (such as evolution). Truth is dangerous. It shall also set you free.
Clergy in turn, need to be courageous in demanding and using that space for the free exploration of ideas. If our denomination is going to have anything of significance to contribute to the commonwealth of ideas and to goodness in general we must affirm freedom of the pulpit.
We need to stick up for each other and defend one another from the bullies and tyrants whether they are trustees of seminaries or publishers of magazines.
This is not about me. Parker Williamson has been bullying people long before I came along. It isn't even about him. Bullies have existed before him. They will exist long after.
But in the faith in which I was raised, bullies don't get the last word.
*For the newly initiated, BFTS = Busybodies, Fusspots, Tattletales, and Scolds. They are everywhere but especially prevalent in churches.